Brief Early History of the Church HISTORICAL DISCOURSE (1876) by REV. WILLIAM H. LITTELL The Church Building Grave Stones and Epitaphs from the Churchyard Pastors of the Church Books about the Church (available at the Emma S Clark Memorial Library) Kate W. Strong, First Presbyterian Church in Brookhaven, at Setauket. Setauket, NY, 1942. Robert Scharff, History of the Setauket Presbyterian Church. Setauket, NY, 1960. (Published to commemorate the three hundredth anniversary of the church.) Belle Barstow, Setauket's Religious Beginnings With Epitaphs from the Presbyterian Churchyard. Smithtown, NY, 1984 Minnesauke School 4th Grade project  web page (Mr. Dick's 4th Grade June 1998)  This is not a church web page.  Found 05/14/2009 from a blog post.

Historic American Buildings Survey/Library of Congress  HABS NY-6276 (ca. 1900)