top of page

SPC Staff

Rev. Johanna.jpg
Rev. Dr. Johanna McCune Wagner

Lead Pastor & Head of Staff

Reverend Doctor Johanna McCune Wagner serves as Lead Pastor and Head of Staff at Setauket Presbyterian Church. Reverend Wagner has been in ministry for 15 years. Prior to joining SPC she was pastor and head of staff at First Presbyterian Church in Concord, CA. She also served as Head of Staff at Trinity Presbyterian Church, St. Louis, MO. In her earlier ministry, Rev. Wagner was Director of Spiritual Life at Culver Academies in Indiana. Ordained in May of 2007, she attended Bryn Mawr College (BA Latin), Cornell University (MA Medieval Studies), Pittsburgh Theological Seminary (M.Div) and Duke Divinity School (D.Min. Christian Leadership).

In addition to her pastoral work, Rev. Wagner and her husband run a not for profit group founded in 2016, 2MIPeople, Inc., which has produced a number of resources to educate the church about issues facing the mental health community. Their most recent work has focused on empowering church leaders to do a more effective job supporting people who are both unsheltered and experiencing serious mental illness.

Rev. Wagner enjoys trail running, hiking, reading and any TV program set in a Scandinavian country. She also enjoys spending time with her husband and their two dogs.

Heidi Parles
Director of Spiritual Formation

Heidi Parles is a long-time member of SPC in a brand new position; Interim Director of Spiritual Formation. She incorporates energy and creativity in her approach to responding to the growing and changing needs of Youth Group, Church School, Confirmation Class as well as programs in Adult Education, some of the primary facets of the role. She has prior experience in teaching Church School, Crib Room Coordinator, and being in leadership of Youth Group. Heidi transitioned to this position after thirty years in the dental field in the local community.  So pearly whites or pearly gates, she's got you covered!

Rev. Ashley McFaul-Erwin
Community Outreach Pastor

Ashley is a lifelong Presbyterian: beginning her journey in the Presbyterian Church in Ireland before moving to the United States in 2011. She studied at Vanderbilt Divinity School and in 2018 was the first openly queer person ordained as a Minister of Word and Sacrament by the Presbytery of Middle Tennessee. During her eight years in Nashville Ashley became invovled with ministry on Tennessee's Death Row, worked in the Juvenile Justice Field, and served as a Chaplain in a drug and alcohol treatment center.


In 2019, Ashley and her wife, Erica, moved to Long Island to join the Setauket Presbyterian Church staff and family. Ashley is a member of the National Board of Directors for More Light Presbyterians, the Three Village Interfaith Clergy Association, the North Brookhaven Sanctuary Cluster, Building Bridges Brookhaven, and the Jobs with Justice AMOS Committee. 


Ashley is a passionate Irish rugby fan, has a mixed up Larne/Nashville accent, and, in the words of her wife,  "has a laugh that can be heard from miles away."

Noby Ishida
Director of Music, Organist

Noby Ishida has coached and conducted opera in New York City for over two decades. He is the founder and Artistic Director of Satori Opera and worked as Assistant Conductor, Chorus Master, and Vocal Coach for Martina Arroyo’s Prelude to Performance program. Mr. Ishida was formerly the Musical Director of the Remarkable Theatre Brigade, and conductor for the Belleayre Music Festival. An accomplished solo and collaborative pianist, he has performed in distinguished venues around the world, and his clients have included artists from major opera companies including the Metropolitan Opera, New York City Opera, Houston Grand Opera, and San Francisco Opera. A dedicated educator, Mr. Ishida has been on the vocal coaching staffs of Temple University, the University of Miami, Bennington College, The New School University, the International Academy of Rome, and was a Visiting Professor and Vocal Coach at Hunter College where he worked with the Hunter Opera Theater helping to train the next generation of singers and collaborative pianists. He is currently a vocal coach for the opera program at Binghamton University and conducts the Festival Chorus and Orchestra at the “Songe d’été en musique” Festival in Quebec.

Image from iOS (6).jpg
Aaron Watkins-Lopez
Church Administrator

Email Aaron

Elizabeth Smith

Communications Coordinator 

Email Elizabeth

Jean Hrbek pictue.jpg
Jean Hrbek

Financial Secretary

Heather Klein

Preschool Threes Teacher

Preschool Co-Director

Denise Elhers

2's Preschool Teacher Assistant

Brooke Cullen.png
Brooke Cullen

Preschool Teacher Assistant

Sarianna Standel

Teacher Assistant

Eva -Bio Picture (2).jpg
Eva Stanganelli

Outreach Operations Manager

Email Eva

Richard A. Holroyd

Church Treasurer

janet craig.webp
Janet Craig

Preschool Director Emeritus

Yvonne Chase

Preschool Fours Teacher

Preschool Co-Director

Mary Elizabeth_edited.jpg
Mary-Elizabeth Silver

Teacher Assistant

Mimi Zaherd.png
Mimi Zahed

Preschool Teacher Assistant


Church Sexton

bottom of page