Welcome to SPC
Worship Sundays 9:30am & 11:00am
Introducing Faithful Conversations, a new speaker series by SPC.
There are a lot of reasons to join a church...
We're here for YOUR why.
Life Celebrations
We are your church when it comes time to mark life’s transitions, its baptisms, weddings, and memorial services.
Support
Our staff is available to provide pastoral care, counseling, and mental health and SUD referrals. You don’t have to face life’s trials alone.
Inclusion
Women and members of the LGBTQIA+ community are represented at all levels of leadership, and their gifts, celebrated.
Service
Passionate about Peace & Justice work? Looking to make a difference? Opportunities to serve abound at SPC.
Introducing our new contemporary worship service.

Wonder what it would be like if a more progressive church were to offer a service with a more contemporary feel? We did, too!
Contemporary music, a sermon, and unscripted prayers, SPC Unplugged meets at 11am in the sanctuary every Sunday.
"Looking for an inclusive and welcoming church home?"
Connect
You are loved. You belong. And we will honor your life experiences and journey. In gratitude to our loving God who meets us where we are, we invite you to join one of our small groups.
We are a serving church with a tradition of starting vital ministries like Open Door Exchange (ODE), the first furniture bank on Long Island. Help us feed people, furnish people’s homes, and provide shelter for people who are unhoused.
Our Church School program introduces children to the Bible through an interactive, hands-on curriculum called Godly Play.
Our teens get support from a Youth Director with a background in social work.
Nursery care is available in our Toddler Room every Sunday.
Children have their own Vocal and Bell Choirs.
Check out Setauket Presbyterian Preschool, where children learn, grow, play, and explore in an atmosphere of love and acceptance, and its new STEAM curriculum.
History
Have you seen the hit AMC series, Turn: Washington’s Spies? If so, you know that SPC has a rich history dating back to the 1600’s and was an integral part of the Culper Spy Ring. Benjamin Tallmadge is buried in our cemetery, as is Abraham Woodhull. History buffs frequently appear at our doorstep to walk our graveyard and tour our sanctuary. We look forward to seeing you here, too!
Reformed and Always Reforming
Worship
Glorify God with us Sunday at services that emphasize Christianity’s relevance,
beautiful music,
and heartfelt prayer.
Connect
Find a supportive community
that will challenge you
to grow your faith
and capacity for service
and selflessness.
Give Back
"Those to whom much is given...."
Change the way you relate
to material goods by
cultivating the freeing
practice of generosity.